Min & Max Capacity SD card?

Get help from the community & developers with the X16 hardware if you can't find the solution elsewhere
Post Reply
SolarSurfer
Posts: 30
Joined: Sun Nov 26, 2023 2:18 am

Min & Max Capacity SD card?

Post by SolarSurfer »

What is the smallest and largest capacity SD card I can use with the CX16?

The only relevant info I could find is in the FAQ, but it only states "Older SD cards with less than 2GB may not be supported."

I got some hits from this forum's search results but those results are dead links (I presume to archived/inaccessible threads). The only solid fact I know is that 8GB is supported, because that's what arrived in the box with my brand new CX16 yesterday :)
SolarSurfer
Posts: 30
Joined: Sun Nov 26, 2023 2:18 am

Re: Min & Max Capacity SD card?

Post by SolarSurfer »

I found this in the CMDR-DOS documentation:
"CMDR-DOS uses the industry-standard FAT-32 format. Partitions can be 32MB up to (in theory) 2TB"
which also doesn't really address how much the CX16 can ... address.

Why I'm asking is I want to by an SD card for daily use and experimenting, and all I know for sure is 8GB works, 2GB "probably won't work", and 2TB works "in theory". But 8GB cards are a lot harder to find than, say, 32GB cards. I don't really have any other use for an SD card, so I'd like to buy something cheap, easy, and compatible.
User avatar
JimmyDansbo
Posts: 476
Joined: Sun Apr 26, 2020 8:10 pm
Location: Denmark
Contact:

Re: Min & Max Capacity SD card?

Post by JimmyDansbo »

Personally I have testet several 16GB cards of different brands without any issues.
The 8GB card that came with the system, obviously works.
I have a 32GB noname card and a 128 GB Samsung card that also work.
So far I have not testet an SD card that did not work.

I think that you should be fairly safe by buying a 32GB card.
Visit my Github repo
or my personal site with CX16/C64/6502 related information.
Feel free to contact me regarding any of my projects or even about meeting up somewhere near Denmark
BruceRMcF
Posts: 224
Joined: Sat Jan 07, 2023 10:33 pm

Re: Min & Max Capacity SD card?

Post by BruceRMcF »

SolarSurfer wrote: Fri Jan 26, 2024 2:49 am I found this in the CMDR-DOS documentation:
"CMDR-DOS uses the industry-standard FAT-32 format. Partitions can be 32MB up to (in theory) 2TB"
which also doesn't really address how much the CX16 can ... address.

Why I'm asking is I want to by an SD card for daily use and experimenting, and all I know for sure is 8GB works, 2GB "probably won't work", and 2TB works "in theory". But 8GB cards are a lot harder to find than, say, 32GB cards. I don't really have any other use for an SD card, so I'd like to buy something cheap, easy, and compatible.
AFAIU, if it uses FAT32, then it seems like an SDHC card should work, since SDHC was originally designed for FAT32. Original SD was the one before SDHC, formatted in FAT12 or FAT16, and SDXC is the one after SDHC, formatted in exFAT.

SDHC cards come in sizes up to 32GB, and the SD Association says that cards that are 32GB should be formatted as FAT32, so if its a 32GB card from a reputable maker, what has been quoted makes it sound like that should be OK.

Note that FAT32 can be formatted up to 2TB, but exFAT is more efficient for drives of that size, so if you have an SDXC card that is 64GB or larger, and it is set up per SD Association Standards, it will be formatted exFAT, so you would have to reformat it to FAT32 to find out if it works.

I would guess that is what the "in theory up to 2TB" means, since a modern 2TB card ought to be formatted exFAT, so it can't be operated as a FAT32 drive until reformatting.

While not yet in common use, the ultra-high capacity SDUC cards are not required to offer SPI mode, so they should be avoided.
Last edited by BruceRMcF on Fri Jan 26, 2024 4:45 am, edited 1 time in total.
mortarm
Posts: 302
Joined: Tue May 16, 2023 6:21 pm

Re: Min & Max Capacity SD card?

Post by mortarm »

> ...But 8GB cards are a lot harder to find...

Um, not really. A simple trip to Amazon revealed these results:
https://www.amazon.com/s?k=8g+sd+cards& ... _sb_noss_1

I'm sure you find something to "buy" here.
SolarSurfer
Posts: 30
Joined: Sun Nov 26, 2023 2:18 am

Re: Min & Max Capacity SD card?

Post by SolarSurfer »

Thanks for all the replies. I'll buy a 32GB SDHC card from the place local to me (I'm not adventurous enough to buy them from amazon!)
TomXP411
Posts: 1785
Joined: Tue May 19, 2020 8:49 pm

Re: Min & Max Capacity SD card?

Post by TomXP411 »

The simple answer is that no one has done thorough testing of which cards work and which do not, so we don't actually know definitively which cards won't work.

If people want to contribute to some sort of "I tried this, and it worked," sheet, we can certainly put something like that up (kind of like we did with the Serial No. Tracker).
SolarSurfer
Posts: 30
Joined: Sun Nov 26, 2023 2:18 am

Re: Min & Max Capacity SD card?

Post by SolarSurfer »

FWIW, the card that shipped with my CX16 was

Silicon Power 8GB SDHC Class 10 SD Memory Card
https://sp-siliconpower.com/products/si ... emory-card
Post Reply